Smartly Payroll vs Xero Payroll: Your ideal Xero alternative

Looking for an alternative to Xero Payroll? 

Sign up
computer

See how easy it is to manage your payroll and people admin with Smartly

Smartly Payroll is the Xero alternative that offers seamless payroll processing with automated payments, specialised support, and easy integration with Xero accounting, all backed by a dedicated Kiwi helpdesk and onboarding team.

Why choose Smartly as your Xero alternative?

#1 rated customer support

We understand that sometimes you just need to talk to someone who knows the ins and outs of payroll. Our Kiwi-based team of payroll specialists are just a call or email away, Monday to Friday, 8am to 6pm, with average phone wait times of 5 minutes or less. Plus our online Help Centre is packed with step-by-step guides and resources to get you started.

Automated payroll payments to staff & IRD

At the click of a button your payroll is sorted! Simply ‘process payroll’ – and we handle the rest. All your payments: to staff, IRD (PAYE and payday filing), KiwiSaver, student loans, child support and more are automatically sorted. You’ll spend less time loading bank files and manually sorting payments and more time working on your business.

Fully supported & compliant onboarding

Our thorough onboarding process means we’ll help identify issues of potential non-compliance from day one. We assist with data extraction and accurate leave balance calculations, reducing compliance risks and helping you pay your staff correctly. With Smartly, you'll never be left to figure it out on your own.

Streamlined integration with Xero

Designed by Kiwis for Kiwis, our software seamlessly integrates with Xero accounting, offering a dedicated payroll solution tailored to New Zealand's unique requirements. We continually update our specialised payroll software to meet the evolving demands of payroll and legislation, giving you confidence in your payroll and compliance processes.

Choose to outsource your payroll to Smartly

Handover all the complex payroll admin to our team of payroll specialists. Your dedicated account manager will work directly with you to set up a payroll process tailored for your business needs and requirements. Our account managers will stay on top of any new legislation changes, like tax and minimum wage change for you.

Keen to know more?

Book a demo with our team to see just how simple payroll can be with Smartly, the ideal Xero alternative.

All the important information you need, right at your fingertips

From setting up new employees, to managing all their information, to sorting their pay and timesheets, Smartly lets you do it all in one place, cutting down your workload and freeing up your headspace.

Xero Payroll comparison

Payroll
Payroll calculations
Automated staff payments
Automated payday filing
Automated IRD and bank payments
Digital timesheets
Employee self-service
Mobile app
Leave management
Labour costing
Reporting
Compliance
Accurate pay history
Automatic software updates for legislation changes
Security
Two factor authentication
ISO27001 security certified
Integrations
Accounting integrations
Time and attendance integrations
Support
Online help centre
Phone support
Email support
Onboarding
Free onboarding
Compliant onboarding
Free training
HR features
Add ons
Plans
DIY
MPS
Pricing
Trial
Monthly fees
Onboarding fees
Variables
Contracts
Smartly Payroll
Advanced reporting
Weekdays from 8am-6pm
One month free
From $50
Free
$2.50 per employee per pay run
No contracts, cancel anytime
Xero Payroll
-
-
-
Basic reporting
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
30-day trial
From $75
No onboarding
$75 accounting plan includes one employee. Upgrade to the next plan for $99 to cover five employees or $119 for ten, with each additional costing $1
Cancel any time

*This information was gathered from online sources on the date of February 2025

What to consider when choosing a payroll provider?

Product Compliance Lead at Datacom and creator of Smartly, Chris Mar, talks about what you should consider when choosing a payroll provider.

Frequently asked questions

1. Does the software help automate the end-to-end payroll process?

Good payroll software assists you throughout the entire payroll process from gathering inputs, automating the tax and net amount calculations and direct crediting employees and the tax department.

2. Does it take the stress out of keeping up with the latest legislation changes? 

Using a payroll system that is automatically updated and helps keep you up to date with any changes to legislation such as, the Holidays Act, PAYE and new payday filing requirements is a must to remain compliant and avoid any unexpected penalties. 

3. Is it compatible with NZ legislation? 

It's fair to say that the New Zealand Holidays Act is like no where else.  And the complex rules to calculate entitlements and rates of pay are very unique to the NZ landscape. Which is why it’s so important to know that you’re choosing a payroll software that understands NZ legislation.

4. Can you get free expert help?

Payroll is an extremely complex subject and it can be a daunting task to try and figure it all out on your own. Whether you want to talk through the latest tax changes or you need help setting up new employees having the support you need is vital to remaining compliant. 

5. Is it easy to use?

Payroll is hard enough without also having to figure out how to use non-intuitive software. If your software is too hard to use the chances of you making a mistake increase significantly and therefore the chances of you becoming non-compliant increase also which is why it’s so important that you are able to run your pays and set up your business with ease.

6. Can you trust your data will remain secure? 

Payroll is full of your employee’s sensitive information so you should be sure to check how your information will be stored when choosing payroll software for your business and what practises and standards are in place to keep your data safe and secure. 

Join the more than 22,000 Kiwi businesses that use Smartly to sort their payroll

Any questions?

Two penguins looking at each other